Quick answer: Hims prices generic sildenafil from roughly $1.63–$4 per dose depending on bundle size, and its Hard Mints (a compounded sildenafil + tadalafil + B12 combo) from about $1.63 per use. MyDrHank's plain generics ($1.66–$2.08/dose) land in a similar range. Rodeo's 4-in-1 compound ($69/month flat) is a different product category from Hims' offerings entirely.
What Hims Actually Sells
Hims is a publicly traded telehealth company (NYSE: HIMS), founded in 2017, with a broad catalog spanning ED, hair loss, weight loss, and mental health. For ED specifically, Hims offers FDA-approved generic sildenafil and tadalafil, brand-name Viagra and Cialis, and Hard Mints — a compounded chewable combining sildenafil, tadalafil, and vitamin B12. Hims doesn't accept insurance for ED treatment.
| Hims | MyDrHank | Rodeo | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Generic sildenafil | ~$1.63–$4/dose | $1.66–$2.08/dose | Not offered separately |
| Compounded combo | Hard Mints from ~$1.63/use | Dissolvable combo (price on request) | 4-in-1 chew, $69/month |
| Subscription required? | Yes, for ongoing pricing | No | Yes |
| Catalog width | ED, hair loss, weight loss, mental health | ED and hair loss only | ED only |
MyDrHank vs. Hims: Plain Generics
For straightforward generic sildenafil or tadalafil, Hims' bundled pricing and MyDrHank's per-dose pricing land close to each other — MyDrHank's lowest advertised price ($1.66) is competitive with Hims' cheapest quarterly-bundle rate. The meaningful difference is commitment: Hims' lowest per-dose pricing typically requires a longer subscription bundle, while MyDrHank has no subscription requirement at all.
MyDrHank
Generic sildenafil, generic tadalafil, and a compounded dissolvable combination formula. From $1.66–$2.08 per dose, no subscription.
View MyDrHankPaid LinkRodeo vs. Hims Hard Mints: Compounded Combos
These aren't quite the same product. Hims Hard Mints combine sildenafil, tadalafil, and vitamin B12. Rodeo's chew combines apomorphine, vardenafil, sildenafil, and tadalafil — a four-ingredient formula including a desire-focused component Hard Mints don't have. Hard Mints' lower per-use starting price reflects a simpler formula, not necessarily a better deal for someone specifically wanting Rodeo's broader ingredient combination.
Rodeo
Apomorphine, vardenafil, sildenafil, and tadalafil in one sublingual chew. $69/month subscription, cancel anytime.
Compounded medication notice: not FDA-approved.
View RodeoPaid LinkIf you specifically want Hims' broader catalog (hair loss, weight loss, mental health under one account), that's a real reason to stay with Hims. If you just want plain generic sildenafil or tadalafil without a subscription, MyDrHank is a genuine alternative at a comparable price. If you want a four-ingredient compounded formula including apomorphine, Rodeo is offering something Hims' Hard Mints don't.